I, and the rest of the world of Netflix viewers, have been watching Bridgerton, a modern-ish take on British romance. The main tension in these stories is rigidity of class based on birth versus achievement based on merit, scheming and overall hotness. In this version, pretty equals good and cheating works when you can get away with it. It borrows a little bit Jane Austen and Oscar Wilde in witty barbs tossed at social conventions, but stays safely in the structure of Downton Abbey where the rules and rank eventually win out.
The American fantasy needs both. We want to enjoy wealth and privilege without effort and a world where effort and hard work is rewarded. In real life, you can’t have both.
Along with struggles of class, there is the constant tension of sex. The upper class women don’t work—even the phrase “working girl” has the connotation of prostitution. In this world, the women working as a singer and seamstress are seen as morally compromised. Life is easier if you are born rich or marry wealthy, but freer if you don’t. Both ways have their rewards and consequences.
Let’s not forget the constant tension of attractiveness. All the ladies have to be pretty and desirable without giving away too much or withholding affection. It helps to be naturally gorgeous without trying too hard. It’s a world were women should be nice to look at themselves without being superficial when it comes the outward appearances of others.
To be fair, the men in these shows have to be good looking too. The ugly or fat ones are the worst in these stories. The handsome ones don’t have it easy either, they also have to be super rich. They need the kind of money that comes from somewhere else. The estate is inherited from their parents obviously, and cash to pay for the non-stop parties comes from rents or production of hardworking people elsewhere. Even the middle-class merchants or working professionals with jobs hardly make it to the show.
The gentlemen all seem to have tailored clothes and clean fingernails. They’re too fancy for physical work, but still strong enough to throw a punch. They all ride horses but never shovel poop.
In a society where being born into the right family is everything, fertility is downright weaponized. Whether you have boys or girls can be the difference in poverty or wealth. Being pregnant outside of wedlock is abominable and refusing or forcing reproduction socially tolerable.
The show is a distraction and relief from our regular lives, but we don’t live there and that’s okay. The current British Royalty is proof that it is all a fantasy. We love that a self-made American woman landed herself a prince. The problem is that kind of coup breaks the very rank it scales. Either birth alone entitles the royalty to their privileges, or hard work and determination beats inherited influence. Once you are used to freedom it is hard to return to confinement. And if you’re free, it means also have responsibilities, and that’s okay too.
