In fiction, the villain is often self-aware, and when cornered, will be quite forthcoming in their diabolical plot as they laugh at the suffering of others. In real life, more often than not, no one sees themselves as the bad guy either before, during or even after they get caught.
On the small scale you start to recognize it in school yard squabbles. No one started the fight. “He hit me first.” “She said a mean thing.” ”They looked at me funny.” “They were ignoring me.” To each party, the other was totally at fault and the other is blamed for the behavior of both. “Look what they made me do.”
We’ve all had that one friend whose exes were all “psycho.” You nod along, but after a while of putting up with your friend’s rudeness, flakiness, and lying, you started to wonder if this so-called friend wasn’t the real problem the whole time.
On the larger scale we see it too. “We did a preemptive strike—if we don’t stop them, who knows how far they’d go.” One country’s traitor is the other’s patriot. One man’s free speech is the other’s agitation and sedition.
I will never forget this earnest justification of past wrong: “My granddaddy was good to his slaves.” This college girl, perhaps aware of the wrongness on some level, repeated the line that smoothed over her complex familial connection. We all know that keeping men and women against their will to serve indefinitely for no compensation, under the threat of physical torture, is wrong, but somehow her relative is spared the judgment and even exalted as the moral anomaly.
“It was a different time.” “Everyone was doing it.” “We had no choice.” “We didn’t know.”
In thirty years or twenty or ten, will these same words be coming out of our lips? Will my grandchildren have to make up intricate stories to explain me away? No one thinks it, because the first person we lie to is ourselves. So, how can we tell? Is there a quiz I can take to see if I am the secret bad guy? What would that look like?
1. It’s okay to punish a person/people group for something someone else did or might do.
2. It’s okay to take something without paying the fair price to make up for some other thing.
3. It’s justified to receive, use, or inherit stolen property.
4. It’s regrettable that this person is suffering, but think of the larger good.
5. I am/we are more deserving than you/them.
6. Others don’t feel pain as much as I do.
7. Those people are not like us.
8. My motives are more moral than others’.
9. We know better than they do.
10. If you did not know, you aren’t responsible.
If you find yourself saying sentences or thinking them, then you too might be harboring some villainy.
This was originally written on 1/4/2020, so if it applies now, that’s not from me.
